Tag Archives: book clubs

Selections from the Hoboken Public Library’s Science Fiction and Fantasy Book Club Part 6: 1984, The Golden Compass, and The Left Hand of Darkness

25 Mar

This is the third year of the library’s Science Fiction and Fantasy Book Club and we’ve read some great books so far including 1984, The Golden Compass and The Left Hand of Darkness.  In April we will be discussing Mary Poppins by P.L. Travers, in May we will discuss Larry Niven’s Protector, and in June we will discuss Jules Verne’s 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea.  I hope you will join us and help plan the books we will be reading for the rest of the year.  Email hplwriters AT gmail DOT com to be added to our mailing list for the group.  You can see previous book club posts here.

George Orwell’s 1984

In January, we rang in the New Year with the dystopian classic 1984 by George Orwell.  We watched the more recent of the two film adaptations that was released in 1984 and starred John Hurt.  Several members of the group had read the book multiple times and it was agreed that repeated readings are beneficial to pick up the many layers of the novel.  Even if you have not read the novel or seen the film you are probably familiar with the character of Big Brother, an omniscient entity watching out for the smallest infraction even if it is something merely thought and not said aloud.  1984 looks at a society where the basic human bonds of familial love, friendship, and romance begin to breakdown.  Some of the group felt the first section of the book moved a little slowly, but it picked up as the main character gradually rebels against the society he is forced to be a part.  Also for those fascinated by linguistics the idea of “Newspeak,” where language is increasingly reduced to the point of absurdity in order to prevent inappropriate thoughts from being even possible, was fascinating and led to a discussion about the way different languages and cultures express concepts uniquely.  The group felt that 1984’s warning about the possibilities for the future are still important today.

Philip Pullman’s The Golden Compass

In February we read one of my favorite fantasies, Philip Pullman’s The Golden Compass.  The group also viewed the recent film adaptation starring Nicole Kidman.  I brought in my replica alethiometer and models of some of the vehicles from the film.  In The Golden Compass, the characters’ souls take the form of daemons which they are able to have as a constant companion for comfort and advice.  I would love to have one and it is fun to imagine if you lived in that universe to think of what form your daemon would take (typically the animal reflects the person’s attitude and personality).  The group enjoyed the book and some of the other members planned to or had read the other books in the trilogy.  Although the group felt the movie lacked some of the complexity of the book, because of time constraints and the desire to make it more child friendly, they still enjoyed both works.  The group members especially liked how the characters in The Golden Compass were multifaceted and were not simply divided into good and evil as in some fantasy works.

Ursula K. Le Guin’s The Left Hand of Darkness

In honor of Women’s History Month, we read Ursula K. Le Guin’s The Left Hand of Darkness, a classic science fiction work with a thought-provoking look at gender.  On the planet Gethen the inhabitants can, during a short period time, be either male or female, but typically exist in an androgynous state.  They are visited by an envoy from the Ekumen, a sort of league of planets all of which of whose inhabitants are divided up into male and female genders.  The Left Hand of Darkness looks at how people would have evolved and interacted in such an environment.  Many of the group felt that the book was more concept than plot driven.   Besides the gender issues that the book brought up, some of the discussion also revolved around Le Guin’s depiction of the cold winter climate on the planet.

Although the group felt The Left Hand of Darkness would make an interesting movie, since it had not yet been adapted as a major motion picture they had picked out the film Tank Girl to view, which stars a strong female protagonist adapted from a comic book series.  The group liked the unique visual aspects of the film which included animation and comic book stills along with the live action.  It was agreed female action heroes and super heroes are only now becoming more celebrated and may have been partially why the movie was not more successful in 1995, when it first came out.

I hope you’ll check out these great science fiction and fantasy works which are all are available in print from the Hoboken Public Library or as an eBook on one our eReaders for loan at the reference desk.  The movies are all available from BCCLS libraries on DVD.

Hope to see you for our discussion of Mary Poppins on Monday April 25 at 6 PM!  There will be a special movie screening beforehand starting at 4 PM (email hplwriters AT gmail DOT com for more details).  The Mile Square City Readers Book Club will meet on Thursday March 31 at 7:30 PM to discuss Opening Belle by Maureen Sherry.  You can get a copy of Mary Poppins or Opening Belle from the Reference Desk.

-Written by Aimee Harris, Head of Reference

The End of Your Life Book Club, by Will Schwalbe

11 Feb

When Mary Ann Schwalbe got pancreatic cancer, it barely slowed her down, initially.  Used to a life of travel, service, and involvement, Schwalbe was intent on fighting her disease with the same fervor she had previously shown when visiting refugee camps is Asia and building libraries in Afghanistan.  Added to her arsenal of top-flight New York doctors and hospitals, Mary Ann had the love and unflagging support of her husband, Sid; and her three children, Will, Doug, and Nina.


Each child, in their own way, brought love and care to their ailing mother but Will’s backing took a unique turn.  Sharing a lifelong love of books and reading with his mother, the two formed perhaps the world’s most exclusive book club.  Each doctor’s visit, each chemotherapy appointment, each hospital stay, and each vacation in Florida or Europe was highlighted by the sharing of new books chosen by the pair for each other, and extensive discussions of the plot, subject, and – as happens in book clubs – application of the book to each person’s life and history.

Learning Mary Ann’s history is one of the joys of this book because Will is a loving and admiring son who has been blessed with an utterly unique mother.  One of the most remarkable (in the sense that I must remark upon it) is that, despite the appearance and practice of WASP privilege, the Schwalbe family comes from Jewish roots on both sides and adopted Protestantism with fervor.  Jewish conversion in the 1940s and 1950s would have been unusual enough, but Mary Ann is devout, with a strong belief in salvation and an afterlife.  She prays, daily, for her children and those around the world that she works to enrich and hopes that her children will, as well.  Will writes of being given the option of attending any Sunday school of his choice, as a child, so long as he attended.  He based his choice of the quality of store bought cookies and ended up with the Christian Scientists to his mother’s consternation.  Will and Doug both attended Protestant-based boarding schools and, after years of required chapel attendance, Will became his mother’s worst nightmare, a Pagan.  Still, Mary Ann’s spirituality informs her life and, one would speculate, contributes to her long term endurance in the fight against her cancer.

Mary Ann was a girl in an era when most women still married and mothered, but she added a third tier and worked in academia as an administrator.  At the behest of an inspiring teacher, Mary Ann believed that she could have it all although she missed the memo that you need “help” to do it all.  As a trailblazer, Mary Ann was frequently the first female chair of Admissions at Radcliffe and Harvard and, later, head of school at upper crust New York private schools.  With a husband who was a manager of arts institutions, two gay children, and endless causes to support, the Schwalbes are the poster family for East Coast elite liberalism.

However, cancer is not selective in its victimization and, while Mary Ann is a formidable fighter, she knows she is engaged in a no-win battle and the only mystery is how long she can keep up her fight given, as she admits, enough money to fill the Medicare “donut hole” without a problem.  Her awareness that others are not as fortunate is admirable and her last words to her friends and family involve asking them to continue the fight for universal medical coverage in the U.S.

One of the things of which one becomes very aware, when reading this book, is that being well read is relative and few people are as well read as Mary Ann and Will.  The appended list of books and authors that the two read and/or discussed runs to six closely spaced pages.  I, for one, have some catching up to do!

In addition to some insightful book discussions, this is a book that deals with the issues of illness and death better than any book I’ve ever read.  In fact, this should be required reading for anyone who gets a cancer diagnosis or has a family member with a terminal illness.  Mary Ann’s level of acceptance is awe-inspiring.  There is no dueling or bargaining with G-d.  She merely says, “Thy will be done,” and proceeds to launch the most amazing fight for her life that has ever been fought.  No trial, no experimental treatment, no traditional route is passed up.  Although Mary Ann says she will choose quality over quantity of life, she nevertheless lasts almost two years beyond predicted diagnoses.

Will admits to insomnia but, other than that, he and his siblings buy into his mother’s wishes that they go about their lives, uninterrupted, until almost the end of Mary Ann’s life.  Only at the very end does Will understand that the ongoing discussions of books and life that he and his mother carry on have revealed a Mary Ann that he did not know.  In fact, when filling out a final “do not resuscitate” form for his mother, he discovers that he has been using her name incorrectly for his whole life.

Much as Randy Pausch and Jeff Zaslow’s The Last Lecture inspired conversations about death and dying a decade ago, this book should restart the discussion now and make us realize that death, even with those we love and think we know well, is often the whispered conversation that we do not want to talk about.  In all of her visits to her numerous doctors, Mary Ann Schwalbe asks about treatment and procedure, but cannot bring herself to verbalize the big question: how long?

I dearly wish I had known Will Schwalbe’s mother.  Actually, in the form of my husband’s aunt, I did know a version of her, but Mary Ann was the “X-treme” version of any highly motivated, extraordinarily committed, capital “L” Liberal that you just have to love.  Mary Ann is the mother I wish I had who tells her children to “go for it” and then goads them into doing the thing that they may not even know that they want to do.

More than anything, however, Mary Ann Schwalbe and her son, Will, share a love of literature and a love of life and an understanding of how books enlighten and enrich our lives in a most exceptional way.  This book should be required reading for just about anyone and should definitely be the beginning of the conversation, not the end.  Highly recommended.

-Written by Lois Rubin Gross, Senior Children’s Librarian

%d bloggers like this: